Louisiana's Living
            Traditions  
Louisiana's Traditional
            Cultures, an Overview
Creole State
            Exhibit  
Virtual Books on
            Louisiana Folklife  
Articles and
            Essays  
Self-Taught Artists
Photographs of
            Louisiana Folklife in Context  
Louisiana Folklife
            Resources  
Louisiana Folklife Maps  
Louisiana Folklife Site
            Homepage  
Site Map of
            the Louisiana Folklife website and All of Its Parts  
Credits  
Site Map and Search  
 
The Louisiana Folklife
            Program  
Louisiana Voices Educator's
            Guide  

Indian Classical Music and Dance in South Louisiana

By Andrew McLean

Introduction
History of Indian Classical Music
Arriving in Louisiana
Cultivating Transcendental Music
Honoring Sarasvati: The Goddess of Music

  • Priyo Majumdar performs "Raga Kafi" on his sarode

  • Saraswati Song Sung By Ramabai Shenoy

  • Meera Seth performs "Bhupali" on her sitar

  • Producing Concerts of Touring Indian Artists
    Extending the Sense of Musical Community
    Storytelling Through Dance
    Conclusion

    Cultivating Transcendental Music
    Burde Kamath's family, including his wife Urmilla, daughter Meghana, and son Mithun are involved in almost all aspects of Indian classical arts as concert producers and students of both music and dance. The scope of their respect and interest in their cultural heritage is vast.

      Here in the U.S., we are missing the music dance, art, and culture. Because they are so ancient, we very much admire the cultural aspects of our Indian-ness; especially the classical music, which we feel we have to treasure. The same goes with Indian dance, the Bharata Natyam. It has much more value than we can imagine. We want to make sure that our children understand it, and as much as possible, like it. (B. Kamath 2008)

    While most Indians keep in touch with their country's sound culture through commercial recordings of popular music (such as popular Bollywood film songs commonly referred to as filmi), television, and more recently the internet, only a small portion of the community takes to classical music. As sarod player Priyodarshi Majumdar states, "This is not popular music; there are very few people who actually like this kind of music." It is not that the Indians do not value their classical music. Compared to the more popular forms of music, it just requires more from both the listener and performer. Local concert producer Subash Kulkarni compares the two forms saying that for filmi music, "If it sounds good and the [lyrics'] meaning is good, it becomes popular. There is a totally different discipline for classical music. In classical music there is the need for a commitment to the training and the teacher." Classical Indian dance instructor Padmini Chari, who has given over twenty years' service to teaching Indian dance in New Orleans and produced several accomplished local dancers, describes this very issue in terms that are equally applicable to music. "When you learn the classical dance you're locked up for five or six years. You don't get anywhere in one year! Whereas, with Bollywood and all that, you can just go and learn and perform. So if you have this fascination for the stage, ... it's Bollywood." The general perception is that classical music has a more serious mood than "light" classical and other forms of Indian music. Classical music requires more active listening to understand its sweet side, so most people who are looking for entertainment or simple distraction prefer the lighter "semi-classical" and film music. Many famous composers and singers of these lighter, more popular styles in fact had classical training and were associates of the classical musicians. Asha Bhosle for example, sometimes called the "Elvis of Indian music," even tied ganda with (became an official disciple of) Ali Akbar Khan who is called the "Bach of Indian music." Local vocal music instructor Sudipta Das elaborates.

      Even in the light classical and more popular songs, you can't sing the details of the melodies if you don't cultivate a basic understanding of classical ragas. Every song still is based on the notes from the ragas. This is a language, and because I've been trained, I can hear that it's based on a certain raga. In classical music, the compositions are very complex and extended and require a lot of skill. You can tell the difference between those who have training to whatever degree and those who don't because of the depth. If you have the training, you can go into those deep notches. Without training, you can't present those deep little notes built into the song. The voice doesn't respond as rapidly. But you have to practice to acquire the speed. Classical training is clearly indicated when fitting-in with the tabla. With the training you can touch those notes and keep in line with the rhythm. (Das 2008)


    Sudipta Das plays the harmonium at the 2008 Saraswati Puja in Kenner, Louisiana.
    Photo: Sadie Ordes.

    The notes of ragas are commonly referred to as sargam. The word sargam) derives its name from the first few notes of the musical scale "Sa, Re, Ga, Ma, Pa, Dha, Ni, Sa," and is roughly equivalent to the solfege of western music, "Do Re Mi Fa Sol La Ti Do." While she taught vocal students in Metairie, Sunita Pethe described her intentions: "First I want them to learn the Indian classical music. Like a base, if the base is ready, you can learn any kind of music. Now they can recognize the various ragas and apply it to any style of music, . . . even western music. As long as they learn the sur [pitch] and the tal [rhythm]." Pethe was the first trained Indian musician to offer vocal classes in south Louisiana, and some of her students have gone on to join bands and choirs of Western music. She continues, "I think they really enjoy it. They know what Indian classical music is, and they can use their music in different parts their activities, and they do. I'm very proud of them. They are using the basics I taught them. They learned and they listen all the time!" One of Pethe's students, Mithun Kamath confirms,

      For me, it's all about the microtones! That kind of indescribable, ... the bending and sliding, … that's what does it. … That's what makes Indian classical music so much more emotional. The kind of music I listen to now reflects the Indian classical music I listened to as a kid. I tend to be interested in things that reflect certain things from Indian classical music. I haven't experimented as far as translating Indian classical music to stringed instruments, …[but] that's why I came to Nirvana [an Indian restaurant], …because I wanted to hear your guitar [a modified sitar-guitar hybrid]. It was awesome! Derek Trucks [famous blues guitarist] has become my all-time favorite guitarist, …and his guitar sounds like a sarode. … Those are the things I'm drawn to now and obviously it's not a coincidence. (M. Kamath 2008)

    Learning to play classical Indian music requires more than listening and technical skills. Mithun's mother Mrs. Urmila Kamath says, "Classical music is not learned easily. We know what effort it takes sadhana / riaz [disciplined, consistent practice] without which the artist cannot shine. I think in India music is a spiritual experience. It's not just something you listen to." Mithun echoes that sentiment, "Music is really the one thing that I identify with the most as far as my identity as an Indian-American, … even more than language and food. It's what I would want to pass on if I could choose one thing. There's just so much involved." When asked what the most important thing for the public to understand about his music culture, he continues, "There's that transcendental nature that may not exist in other music. … It's just so tied up in the spiritual and meditative side of our culture. Something in it can transfix you."

    Honoring Sarasvati: The Goddess of Music
    While seasoned musicians will typically perform at house concerts and a variety of public and private events, the students' yearly recitals give them an opportunity to show what they've learned and ask for blessings in their continued studies. For those students or teachers associated with the Indian state of Bengal, recitals are traditionally given during the annual puja (prayer service) held in the first part of spring called Sarasvati Puja. According to Hindustani vocalist and professor of Religious Studies Dr. Guy Beck of Kenner, "The Goddess Sarasvati is venerated by all students and performers of Indian music as the divine patron of music and learning: indeed she personifies the power of sound and speech" (Beck 2007). In typical images, Sarasvati is carrying sacred books (the Vedas) and musical instruments while birds gather around her graceful presence. The Louisiana Bengali Cultural Association (LBCA) held this years' Sarasvati Puja at Woodlake Country Club in Kenner. The day was divided into morning and evening segments. The morning service was adult oriented including elaborate offerings of flowers, oils, sweet foods, and incenses to the goddess along with the lengthy recitations of ancient, traditional Vedic verses by presiding priest, Dr. Ashim Bhattacharya, and of course, a communal meal and socializing.


    Goddess Saraswati altar at the
    Majundar home in Metairie, Louisiana.
    Photo: Rebecca Carter.

    The evening portion brought the children into focus with the much-anticipated "Cultural Program." On this day, it was clearly more important to simply participate than to offer an excellent performance. The program featured mostly children in a light-hearted, but steady upward progression of proficiency, which culminated in the more mature music and dance items from those who had obviously been studying. Some sang their favorite pop song a capella or in karaoke style with a CD recording, while others recited new and traditional poetry. In one of the program's more mature items, Monika Roy, a long-time student of Padmini Chari, presented a condensed version of a two-hour Natyanjali dance recital she had prepared for six years. Prema Bhattachaya sang a few light classical songs accompanied by her teacher Sudipta Das on harmonium and Tushar Roy on tabla. Vocalist Sumaitha Chowdhury, a recent immigrant from Bangladesh, accompanied herself on harmonium with Tushar Roy's tabla. Arnab Ray gave an eloquent speech reminding the community that the swan image often depicted in paintings of Sarasvati represents the discernment that turns the knowledge into wisdom and judgment.

    One such musician who exemplifies such discernment in transmitting the classical music tradition is Priyodarshi Majumdar. "Priyo," as he is called, initiated his training as a classical sarode player in Calcutta as a young teenager. During an eleven-year apprenticeship to his guru Sri Robi Chakraborty, his lessons would last for several hours every Saturday at the guru's home where he was virtually adopted as a son. The lessons included learning to vocalize all aspects of the music while developing the techniques required to articulate the music on his instrument. Before relocating to New Orleans to pursue an engineering degree at Tulane in the early 1990s, Majumdar had won music competitions in the state of Bengal, and his proficiency instantly earned him a reputation as the most respected instrumentalist in Louisiana's Indian community. From his Metairie home, he has taught select students and performed at numerous Indian social gatherings as well as represented the Indian community locally in prestigious events such as the New Orleans Jazz and Heritage Festival.

    Priyo Majumdar performs "Raga Kafi" on his sarode

    Meera Seth performs "Bhupali" on her sitar

    Priyo attends the LBCA's Sarasvati Puja to honor all the arts and forms of learning but hosts a private puja in his home specifically for his student recitals. He explains,

      This is traditional music and I've learned it in a very traditional way. Since I have been so fortunate to have a guru who transferred all whatever he could and I whatever I could take from him. I try to at least carry on that same tradition here. I don't have to, but I like playing it and if I can help someone to play it and enjoy it, why not! My son is six years old and it's almost like a given that my son will learn up to a certain point. Then we'll see if he enjoys it and wants to keep it up. (Majumdar 2008)


    Prokkawn Majumdar takes lessons to
    play the sarode at his home in Metairie.
    Photo: Rebecca Carter.

    At the LBCA puja, Majumdar's son Prokkawn saved his sarod recital for the home puja and opted instead to present a few poems he had memorized for the community puja. Before Prokkawn's recital began, Ramabai Shenoy, a respected elder in the community, asked if she could sing an opening invocation to the goddess Saraswati to set the tone of the event. Click here to hear Saraswati song sung by Ramabai Shenoy. The lyrics and translation are below.

    Amba Devi Saraswati
    Ananda Roopini Palaya Mam
    Trailokya Janani DEVI
    Ananda Roopini Palaya Mam
    Vinavadini Saraswati
    Ananda Roopini Palaya Mam
    Mayura Vahini Saraswati
    Ananda Roopini Palaya Mam

    Amba, Devi, Saraswati
    who is blissful, protect me
    She is the mother of the universe
    who is blissful, protect me
    She is playing the Vina (her instrument)
    who is blissful, protect me
    She is riding the peacock (her vehicle)
    who is blissful, protect me

    Andrew McLean is an ethnomusicologist and professional musician who specializes in Indian Classical Music. He is based in New Orleans, Louisiana where he performs and teaches the guitar and Indian tabla (drums).

    NEXT - Producing Concerts of Touring Indian Artists

     

    National Endowment for the Arts.

     
    Folklife in Louisiana Home | Living Traditions Home | Louisiana Voices: Educator's Guide
    Folklife Program Introduction | Planning and Funding Folklife Projects
    Overview of Louisiana's Traditional Cultures | News, Events & Programs
    Links | Site Map & Search | Credits | Contact Us/Link to Us
    Louisiana Division of the Arts | Department of Culture, Recreation & Tourism
    Copyright 1999 Louisiana Division of the Arts,
    PO Box 44247, Baton Rouge, LA 70804, tel 225-342-8180