He's The Prettiest: A Tribute To Big Chief Allison "Tootie" Montana's 50 Years Of Mardi Gras Indian Suiting
New Orleans has often been referred to as America's most African city and considered part of the Caribbean world. While it is acknowledged that our city's origins are European, predominantly French and Spanish with an influx from Italy and Ireland, it remains that a major component of New Orleans' cultural gumbo stems from its associations with Africa and/through the Caribbean. African Americans have had an indelible impact on the city's lifestyle and customs. In passing, mention must be made of the origins and development of perhaps their most agreed-upon contribution--jazz--America's quintessential musical idiom. Later rhythm & blues, rock & roll have early roots in this musical mecca. One cultural phenomenon unique to the Crescent City and coming from African ritual traditions is the jazz funeral. Yet another apparent contribution from African Americans on New Orleans culture is its distinctive cuisine derived from Africa as well as Europe and Native American peoples indigenous to the area.
Without a doubt the century-old tradition of certain New Orleans' African-American males dressing on Mardi Gras day in elaborate handmade costumes reminiscent of the American Plains Indian dress and the beadwork of Yoruba peoples in Nigeria ranks high in our city's unique contributions to American culture. It too has associations which stem from Africa by way of the Caribbean. This exhibition celebrating the singular achievements of the Big Chief of the Yellow Pocahontas tribe and the recognized dean of all the Big Chiefs of the Mardi Gras Indians, Allison "Tootie" Montana, presents to the public this folk art form which has been overlooked by many in the art world for many years. On this occasion the New Orleans Museum of Art honors all the "gangs" and their chiefs for the extraordinary work they have done with little or no notice throughout the years. Some of the more recent chiefs who formed groups originated as members of the Yellow Pocahontas. Joe Pete Adams of the Seminole Indians, Larry Bannock of the Golden Star Hunters, Ferdinand Bigard of the Cheyenne Hunters, Monk Boudreaux of the Golden Eagles, "Lil" Walter Cook of the Creole Wild West, Emile "Bo" Dollis of the Wild Magnolias, Lawrence Fletcher and later Jake Million of the White Eagles, Victor Harris of the Spirit of Fi-Ya-Ya, Donald Harrison, Sr. of the Guardians of the Flame, George Landry, known as Big Chief Jolley, of the Tchoupitoulas, Percy "Chief Pete" Lewis of the Black Eagles and Charles Taylor of the Yellow Jackets are legendary in the pantheon of individuals participating and keeping alive this tradition.
In 1987 Chief Montana was the recipient of a Fellowship as a Master Traditional Artist from the Folk Art Program of the National Endowment for the Arts in Washington, D.C. [In 2002, he was featured in the DVD-rom, Masters of Traditional Arts on Heritage Fellowship winners.]
While affording the opportunity to document and acclaim the artistic accomplishments of Chief Montana, this publication focuses on the various theories and beliefs regarding the origins and history of this New Orleans phenomenon. Although it is acknowledged there is no general consensus concerning this issue, hopefully some further clarity can be elicited in this ongoing discussion. New Orleans writer and poet Kalamu ya Salaam, a close friend and biographer of Montana, has contributed a thought-provoking essay here. The beautiful colorful photographs printed in this catalogue and blown up on the gallery walls are the work of Chandra McCormick and Keith Calhoun with assistance from Harold Baquet. This husband and wife team collaborated with videographers Will Horton and Arnold Bourgeois to create the fascinating video running continuously in the gallery and documenting the entire process of creation of "the last suit" from the design and sewing to the Chief's "last practice" as a local bar and his appearances in the streets on Mardi Gras and Super Sunday. My sincere appreciation to Dr. Maurice Martinez, who has done pioneering work for many years on the origins of of Indians in New Orleans, for his deep interest in and wise counsel, for this current project honoring Big Chief Montana.
The museum is grateful to those who have recognized the importance of this exhibition and contributed to its success. I am most appreciative of Barbara Louivere's interest in making possible a generous grant from Southeast Medical Alliance of Metairie to underwrite the costs for this publication and for programming in the form of concerts and beading workshops. Thanks goes to the Louisiana Endowment for the Humanities for the funding of the marvelous video. Additional support for the video is provided, courtesy of Alden McDonald, by the Liberty Bank and Trust Company of New Orleans and the Louisiana Black Heritage Festival Committee.
I am indebted to Lee Morais of the Museum's staff for his interest and technical assistance in the making of the video.
The Mayor of New Orleans, Marc H. Morial, and his director of the Office of Tourism and Arts, Sandy Shilstone, have enthusiastically endorsed this tribute to one of New Orleans' outstanding citizens and have been most supportive of the project. I am pleased that, if for no other reason, a new and lasting friendship between the Chief and myself has evolved through the development of this exhibition. He is a true gentleman and I thank him for allowing the museum to show his suits. Last, but certainly not least, I want to extend my gratitude to the entire Montana family who have welcomed me into their homes and given their full cooperation to this effort. The Chief's wife, Joyce, has, over the years, given her complete dedication and assistance to her husband's Indian work and been a comfort to all the family and the Yellow Pocahontas gang. It has been a pleasure working with the Chief's son and successor Darryl and his wife, Sabrina, of the New Orleans Traditional Culture Exchange, Inc., in arranging the multitude of details necessary to coordinate the artist with the Museum. Fred Johnson, as the Chief's production manager for this past Mardi Gras, was most helpful to me for which I am grateful.
New Orleans is a wonderful place to live and work, and the Mardi Gras Indians, as one of the jewels in the city's crown, are one of the reasons that make it so.
William A. Fagaly
New Orleans Mardi Gras Indians and Tootie Montana
by Kalamu Ya Salaam
All art is folk art. Some artifacts are manufactured for commercial reasons or are commissioned by the wealthy, others for utilitarian purposes of simply for pleasure. Some artifacts encompass or exemplify the cultural values of their time, others ostentatiously break with tradition (in the process creating a new tradition and enriching the old tradition--there is no escaping one's cultural legacies). Nevertheless, these, and other important distinctions notwithstanding, all art is created by "folk," by people. However all art/artisans do not represent the same class, ethnic, and cultural backgrounds. Nevertheless, whether produced by trained professionals or vocational autodidacts, urban sophisticates, or rural recluses, self-conscious creators intent on stretching the boundaries of their discipline or truly naïve innovators simply doing what pleases them, art is essentially humanity expressing itself. As we broaden our appreciation of the category commonly known as "fine art" (sometimes called "high art"), activities, artists, and artifacts which were previously overlooked or taken for granted are now examined more closely. Such is the case with the New Orleans Mardi Gras Indians. They are a particularly interesting expression of what is labeled "contemporary folk art," and Allison "Tootie" Montana is one of the most revered creators in this tradition.
Big Chief Allison Montana in 1997 suit on Super Sunday. Photo Chandra McCormick.
The Mardi Gras Indians are called folk artists essentially because they are self-taught, non-institution sponsored, seemingly craft-centered artisans. They have been studied but never definitively defined, documented but never successfully duplicated. Do we understand them by focusing on their hand-sewn suits or on their rituals, the skill of a particular chief at sewing, singing, or dancing--can any part be comprehended without some feel for the whole? Indeed, who and what are the Mardi Gras Indians?
The Mardi Gras Indian tribes (or "gangs") of New Orleans are community-based, socio-cultural institutions over a century old. Like blues, jazz, and other deeply rooted examples of African-American culture, "Injuns" (as neighborhood people affectionately refer to them) date back to the post-reconstruction era. Exactly when and why the colorfully costumed, neighborhood-based gangs started is shrouded in uncertainty but most accounts point to the late 1800s, a significant period of racist repression and outright terror. On September 14, 1874, "Ex-Confederates of the newly formed White League barricaded streets, attacked, and killed many of the interracial Metropolitan Police, and seized the state capitol, which, at the time, was the old St. Louis Hotel. " 1 The Leaguers temporarily installed city officers--within three weeks they were removed. Although they were unable to dominate militarily after the infamous battle, this did mark the beginning of the hey day of segregation in a city which had known slavery under the French and Spanish but which had also always been racially mixed and had also had a significant element of free Blacks.
On a more positive note, 1884 to 1885 marked the celebration of a world's fair, the Cotton Centennial Exposition, which historian Leonard Huber assessed "while not a financial success, restored to New Orleans a feeling that the city was at last recovering its former commercial importance.2
These two events are often considered seminal elements in the founding of Mardi Gras Indians. The structures of Jim Crow ensured that the Indians would be a phenomenon that existed cocooned within predominately Black and/or mixed Black/immigrant residential neighborhoods. There would be no Mardi Gras Indian activity up and down Canal Street, St. Charles Avenue or within the riverfront area of the French Quarter. During the 1880s not only the Mardi Gras Indians but also many other benevolent societies, particularly the neighborhood-based Social Aid & Pleasure Clubs (SA&PC) were also founded. This was a period of organizing within the Black community both for self-defense (both literal terms of withstanding segregationist terror and figuratively in terms of associations of mutual aid), as well as organizing for self-expression in formal as well as informal artistic expression--for example, here is when we witness the advent of professional bands, orchestras, and traveling theatrical/musical troupes.
The Cotton Centennial is credited by some historians as indirectly providing the raw inspiration for the Mardi Gras Indians' use of the "Indian costume" motif. In 1884 to 1885, concurrent with the Centennial, the Buffalo Bill Wild West Show wintered into New Orleans, and, according to cultural documentarian Michael Smith, "performed regularly, over a four month period, before large crowds in a popular black recreation area known as Oakland Park and Riding Stables (now the New Orleans Country Club)."3 Smith and others speculate that "50 to 60 Plains Indians, including four chiefs, were likely on the streets in New Orleans in their native dress during Mardi Gras 1885."4 Historians who accept Smith's thesis argue the Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show was the genesis of the Mardi Gras Indians. They specifically point to the name of Creole Wild West to support their argument. Unfortunately, for this point of view, none of the Mardi Gras Indians recall any references to Buffalo Bill's show and some of the Indians, Tootie Montana included, resent the implication that the masking Indian was started by or inspired by Buffalo Bill's show.
There is no disputing that the first Mardi Gras Indian tribe, the Creole Wild West, was formed in the mid-to-late 1880s. Cultural historian Maurice Martinez, who also made the first in-depth Mardi Gras Indian film (The Black Indians of New Orleans, 1976) is emphatic in identifying the inception of Mardi Gras Indian tradition. "How did the Mardi Gras Indian tradition get started? In the 1880s, a young man of Indian and African descent masked on Carnival Day as an Indian. This man was the great uncle of Allison "Tuddy" [sic] Montana, today's Big Chief of the Yellow Pocahontas tribe."5 Despite the uncertainty as to a specific date and the lack of definitive information about who else and how many were in the first gang, most knowledgeable observers (ranging in outlooks from Martinez to Smith) suggest the late 1880s as the birth of Mardi Gras Indians in New Orleans.
However if we step back a moment and look at the Caribbean basin as a whole and look at colonial records in some detail we will note two important phenomenon. One, Mardi Gras Indians are not unique to New Orleans and two, costuming as Indians during Mardi Gras preceded the 1880s. Writing in the catalogue for the exhibition Caribbean Festival Art , Barbara Bridges notes:
The Mardi Gras Indians exemplify the creolization at the heart of the pan-Caribbean and North American influences converging to create a fresh aesthetic is similar to what occurred in the West Indies. And although the Amerindian form appears with variations in Toronto, Brooklyn, London, Trinidad, St. Kitts-Nevis, Brazil, Cuba, Jamaica, Bermuda, and the Bahamas, nowhere else is it accompanied by quite the same musical refrains, aesthetic form, and artistic technique that characterized New Orleans' Black Indians.6
Bridges is, of course, arguing that New Orleans is the most artistic manifestation of a cultural phenomenon common to the Caribbean basin. Art historian Ute Stebich writing in the Brooklyn Museum's catalogue for the Haitian Art exhibition suggests that Mardi Gras Indians were central to Haitian celebrations. "No carnival parade is complete without a group of Indians. Indian costumes are the most magnificent of all, exemplifying the Haitians' sense of color and the work and love that goes into the detailed planning of masquerades."7 While it is difficult to argue for one national group over another, certainly the development is larger and more pronounced in New Orleans (with sometimes as many as twenty tribes from the 1880s on) than in any of the other Caribbean-basin regions where Mardi Gras Indians are celebrated.
Why New Orleans? On the one hand New Orleans is uniquely Caribbean rather than North American in its early history and cultural development, and as a result is the only place in the United States where Mardi Gras is celebrated as a major holiday similar to other parts of the western hemisphere--Mobile, Alabama, actually has an older Mardi Gras celebration but it is much less developed in both size and community participation at all class and ethnic levels. On the other hand, New Orleans also shares the cultural history of the United States, and Native peoples are more interwoven into the cultural fabric of the United States than in other countries in the Americas.
Paradoxically, the high visibility of Native peoples in the USA may be because the armed resistance of Native Americans, especially in the "wild west," had a longer, stronger, and more successful history in the United States than anywhere else in the Americas. Active, armed Native resistance to colonialism continued through the turn of the twentieth century. Additionally, there was a higher incidence of African and Native amalgamation in the United States unlike in the Caribbean where the native populations were generally physically eliminated altogether and thus did not provide the opportunity for amalgamation on the order of Seminoles and Blacks in Florida or Blacks and Natchez in the Louisiana territory. In any case, there is a strong historical basis for Native-American images in the general American cultural consciousness as well as a more pronounced and subversive meaning of these images for African-Americans.
Also, as Smith notes, both active collaboration between Indians and Africans as well as the "imaging" of Native-Americans by African-Americans dates back to the 1700s. Drawings by A. Debatz suggest the merging of African and native Indian cultures in Louisiana as early as 1735. In 1781 the Spanish governor forbade "masking, the wearing of feathers, gathering at local taverns, and public dancing by negroes" during the carnival season, hinting at what may have been the precursors of "Indian" gangs. Already by then it seems, the collective public fetes of the Afro-Indian-Creole population had developed sufficiently to pose a problem of public order (as perceived by whites). 8
Clearly, the historical background suggests that the idea of "masking Indian" is over two hundred years old. Rather than an anomaly, the Mardi Gras Indians are in fact simply a manifestation of a much broader and older cultural trend than is often supposed. Rather than unique to New Orleans, Mardi Gras Indians are better understood as representative of the historic merging of African and Native peoples--a merger which happened throughout the so-called "new world" both because of as well as in spite of African enslavement and Native genocide.
The Background of Big Chief
On an individual or micro level, more so than any other currently active Mardi Gras Indian, Allison Marcel Montana personifies both the richness and complexity of the New Orleans Mardi Gras Indian tradition. Born December 16, 1922, and nicknamed Tootie by his beloved cousin Bea ("my mother's first cousin") when he was very young, Montana's Mardi Gras Indian heritage stretches back through his father and his grandmother's brother.
Montana's great uncle, "B.K." (sometimes called "Becate") Batiste, was the legendary founding Big Chief of the Creole Wild West, widely celebrated as the first Mardi Gras Indian tribe. Montana's father, Alfred, was a Big Chief of the Yellow Pocahontas, a tribe which grew out of the Creole Wild West.
Moreover, at seventy-four, Big Chief Tootie Montana is the oldest continuously masking Mardi Gras Indian in New Orleans. He began masking on his own in 1947 and continued for forty straight years before taking a one-year break after Mardi Gras 1986. In 1988 he resumed and capped his long tenure as Big Chief of the Yellow Pocahontas with a decade-ending last March this past Mardi Gras 1997.
Big Chief Allison Montana and wife Joyce at home working on 1997 suit.
Although his father dressed him when Tootie was seven years old, Montana did not actively mask until he was a young man of twenty-five. In the interim years, Montana fondly remembers that for about three years in his early teens he masked as a "skeleton." The Mardi Gras Indians were not the only Mardi Gras masking tradition in the New Orleans Black community. In addition to the Zulu Social Aid & Pleasure Club which sponsors a famous parade, there were also the Skeletons and the Baby Dolls, plus a great deal of cross-dressing by informal groups and individuals. Tootie recalls they had about fifteen members in their skeleton gang, dressed in black, white painted bones on large sculptured heads made of enamel painted cheesecloth stretched over wire frames.
Born and reared at 1313 St. Anthony Street between Dorgenois and Morais, Montana's background was Creole. He speaks fluent Creole French. Tootie's parents were separated and he grew up in an extended household of siblings, mother, grandparents, cousins, and in-laws. "It was twenty-one of us living in the house. During those times, people didn't worry about living rooms. There was six bedrooms and three kitchens."10 The men in his family were plasterers and carpenters or related occupations, and Allison eventually apprenticed into the metal lathing trade. This social background prepared Tootie both to understand inter-group dynamics and to do creative work with his hands.
The urge to mask hit Tootie in 1947 after he had returned from a three-year stint in California working in shipyards during World War II. His father, who had retired from masking, had decided to start up again when friends asked Tootie's father to be the Big Chief of a new gang they were pulling together. Tootie decided to mask under his father.
Big Chief Allison Montana and Darryl Montana, Big Chief's son and successor, in their 1997 suits. Photo Keith Calhoun.
Tootie's first costume was a "two-week wonder" and his second year masking became the occasion for him to forever break the bond of dependency on others to design and fashion any part of his suit. In 1947 private phones in Black households were nearly nonexistent. Tootie recalled, "I went to his house several times and missed him. So one Saturday, carnival was about two weeks away. I sat on his step for hours and hours--here he comes that Saturday evening. 'Hey, what are you doing around here?' he asks me. I said, 'Man, I've been looking for you a couple of weeks.' He said, 'Yeah, what's the matter?' He got serious. He thought something had happened. I said, 'No, I heard you were pulling a gang from the Eight Ward.' He said, "Yeah, Charlie Brown came and got me.' So I said, 'That's what I had come to see you about. I'm interested. I want to mask.' He laughed at me. He said, 'Oh boy, you've got to be kidding.' I said, no. He said, 'You know Carnival ain't but two weeks off. Can you make a suit that fast.' I said , 'Oh yeah, and I did.'"11
Tootie completed the suit in time but relied on his father to make the crown which didn't get delivered to Tootie until the night before Carnival. After two years of his father making his crown, Tootie vowed to never rely on anyone else again. The second year Tootie Montana masked he was so beautiful, Robert Guidry, the chief who had replaced Tootie's father who declined to mask again, "Whispered in my ear, he said 'Man look, you're prettier than I am.' He said, 'You go ahead and be the chief.' I said, 'No, you're chief this year."12
In 1949 Tootie Montana founded his own gang, the Monogram Hunters, and in approximately 1956, after the Yellow Pocahontas had been inactive for a year, Tootie changed the name of the Monogram Hunters and reformed as the Yellow Pocahontas. He served as Big Chief through 1997 when Tootie Montana passed the stick to his son Darryl "Mutt-Mutt" Montana.
Early on, two of Montana's most important characteristics were established. One, his leadership abilities easily won the confidence of his peers. "You see, everybody can't be a chief. A person who masks under you, they have to look at you as a superior in order for them to give you the respect and for you to be their leader. They've got to have that feeling."13 The other was Tootie's genius at designing costumes.
"A lot of people think that my father showed me how to make Indian costumes, but he never showed me anything. As a matter of fact, he was surprised. He didn't want to see me out do him either. He had the history for having a pretty crown. If you are really into this like my daddy was and like I am, then you're really proud. I learned by making mistakes. One thing about making those crowns, their feathers didn't flop. Their feathers stay sewn down tight. They didn't move. And he had made the star crown--a new type of crown. I said, 'You know, I remember you having that star crown years ago. I want to make that crown, but how would you make it that it flop?" He just looked at me, put his hand on his chin, and smiled. He would never tell me how it would go. He shook his head like it couldn't be done. But I was determined. I was only sorry that I made that crown after he was dead."14
Tootie Montana has been a major innovator in suit design. He developed the full-length trail crown that spread out horizontally from side to side instead of lengthwise sticking out behind the chief. Moreover, on Montana's suit "Every piece was put on there one at a time. You pick up a sequin, you pick up a bead; even the beads around a stone are threaded and you hook them up one at a time. I use glue after my pieces are put together. I make my pieces like a puzzle."15
Detail of 1990 suit. Photo Keith Calhoun.
Montana also made major innovations in the use of abstract geometric, three-dimensional figures in addition to representational designs. "Everybody was flat. I was flat until I wanted to be different and then I just started doing it. I started raising my pieces up. My daddy did a little--not three-dimensional, he used the carton that the eggs came in."16 Although it is traditional for Mardi Gras Indians to sew a new suit each Carnival, Montana has excelled as an innovator. His creative genius seems inexhaustible.
Additionally, Tootie Montana has made major contribution in moving the Mardi Gras Indians away from physical violence to aesthetic competition. "I'm the one who changed it from fighting with the guns to fighting with suits. Everybody in the city, even the rag men, in their mind they think they can outdo me. They be sewing to beat me and they get fooled every time.
"My father changed a lot. They had a Magnolia Bridge, not too far from where the Superdome is now. It was a little pontoon bridge any tribe they crossed over that bridge meant they were going to humbug---they used the word "humbug" to mean fight. But my daddy crossed it every year. My daddy was a son-of-a-gun. And he had people with him like Spy Boy Dolphy and Lil Yam Springham. They used to mask with capes over their shoulders. They didn't wear those big heavy crowns like I wear because they had to run. When they would get ready to meet another tribe they would close that cape, fold their arms, and have their hand right on that gun in their waistband. When they'd meet the enemy they would tell them humba. Humba is a Creole word that means get down, set down, or put down."17
Eventually, after repeatedly going uptown every year, the Yellow Pocahontas under Alfred Montana's leadership became so feared that other tribes stopped fighting them and the actual fighting began to die down.
An African-American Art Form
Because of his family history, Tootie Montana is also a repository of Mardi Gras Indian traditions including singing, dancing, and drumming. Few, if any, can match Tootie's knowledge of the traditions surrounding the use of chants and songs, and no one has been able to top his stirring rendition of the anthem, "Indian Red."
Detail of 1993 suit. Photo Keith Calhoun.
"I sing Indian Red like my daddy sang it. It's a hymn, like a spiritual. They use that song to open your practice and it is also to identify each member of the tribe and what position they're carrying."18
So while we admire his suits we should not overlook his contributions as a vocalist and dancer, nor should we minimize the genre-changing import of his leadership abilities. Certainly the suits are the most striking aspect of the Mardi Gras Indian tradition, but there is a deeper aesthetic than costuming at work. Musicologist John Miller Chernoff, who has intimately studied the social function of African music, argues:
In African societies, music fulfills functions which other societies delegate to different types of institutions. In Africa, musical events provide a focus for personal character and encourage the socialization of indigenous philosophical and moral ideals: respect, patience, flexibility and adaptability, collectedness of mind, composure in the exercise of power and in the toleration of powerlessness, a sense of pluralism, and a sense of balance in the perception of personal character and generational filiation. Music serves a crucial integrative function within many types of institutionalized activities, and musicians perform a complex social role in community occasions. Music and dance sometimes provide the generative dynamics of large- and small-scale social movements.19
Chernoff could easily have been describing in detail the function of Mardi Gras Indians in the Black community and especially the influence that Tootie Montana has exerted on both preserving positive Mardi Gras Indian traditions and elevating some of the less savory aspects, especially physical warfare.
This traditional art form has changed over the years but the basic elements remain intact. The seminal elements of Mardi Gras Indian culture are threefold. One is masking. Two is procession. Three is ritual. In the case of Mardi Gras Indians, the masking element of the culture offers multiple levels of interpretations. African cultures traditionally use the mask as a vehicle to connect the here and now to the spirit world; to invite the gods to possess the body and to transport the body to another plane of existence. Whether one accepts or understands this level is irrelevant to the fact that masking is near universal among sub-Saharan and particularly West Coast African peoples. Dancing, singing, and parading on Mardi Gras day (or at Indian practices), the Mardi Gras Indians often enter the spirit world of possession akin to catching the spirit in Black church services or being ridden by loa in a voodoo service.
Montana explains, "If you're for real and you do it all those years I did it with no excuse, they can't hold you back when you get on that floor. It's just like a sister in church. You're dancing with a spirit, with a feeling. If there are five or six chiefs in my practice, I'll out dance all of them until they short-winded and they have to run outside looking for air. I'll still be on the dance floor soaking wet. Look like I can't stop. My duty was to out dance every one of them. I'm just dancing with a spirit. I'm not just dancing to be dancing."20
The second level of masking is to hide one's essence within a socially acceptable form. In this case the spirit of resistance is "masked" as a Mardi Gras activity. In the early years, Mardi Gras Indians would actually fight each other as well as anyone who got in their way. The loose translations of some of the chants refer to "refusing to bow down" and "kiss my ass." The militant assertion is more than simply macho-inspired behavior, especially when presented in the guise of Indians, the people who waged armed struggle against colonialism.
The third level of masking is the goal of body adornment which is socially acceptable to the dominant cultures within the context of Carnival. The desire to produce beauty in dress, beauty in song, and beauty in dance pushes each Indian to and beyond their creative limit. The chiefs in particular tend to be men who take extreme pride in their personal appearance.
The multiple levels of masking are sometimes so complex that even the participants are not self-consciously aware of all the possible meanings. Tootie recalls seeing Aztec and African sculpture in a museum.
"It was shocking the year I won the National Endowment Award in '87 [Washington, D.C.], we went to New York and Maurice Martinez brought us to a museum. About a quarter of block from where I was standing I could see something look like sculpture and I said, 'Let's go look at that.' Man, when I walked up there, the funniest feeling came over me. I said, 'Lord!' Joyce [Tootie's wife] said, 'Look at that, you remember you had that.' And Maurice too, he said, 'Remember, you wore that same design.' A design that just came out of my head. And it was not one but several pieces that I've done through the years on my suit, particularly in front of my crown. I looked. Three thousand years ago somebody did that. I said, 'I'll be dog-gone.' That stood on my mind. It hit me kind of funny and stayed on my mind. I knew I had never been to New York, less alone been to that museum. It was no copy job. I think my creativity is greater than copying. Like people get books and copy things out of a book. I don't trust that. I know they made more than one book."21
Tootie had never seen Aztec stone sculpture and traditional African beadwork before except in its "masked form as Mardi Gras Indian crowns and beadwork.
The element of procession is an equally important part of the aesthetic. Unlike the Eurocentric tradition of a centralized place (museums, galleries, exhibitions, etc.) which the people go to in order to view the best artwork, the African tradition emphasizes literally moving the art through the community. Again, the tradition is "masked" as a Mardi Gras parade which is both acceptable to the dominant society and within the means of the Black community. Again, Tootie offers an interesting insight. He maintains that his first ten years of masking Indian was, "for myself. The rest of the time, those other forty years were for the people. After you do it for so many years and you get involved and you get to be the people's person, you have a lot of feeling for the people. They make you do a lot of things. Right now, when I'm making a suit, I be saying, 'Boy, wait until the people see this.' That's what I sew for."22
The third element is ritual. The formation of societies with secret codes, a specific hierarchy, plus regulations and obligations to be met serve as major focus of socialization by organizing and teaching young men how to be responsible members of their community. "If you're serious about it--I hear guys masking for a year or so and then missing. No excuses if you're serious. I've had all kinds of problems: separated, divorced, buying a house, spending money to repair it, no work--the type of work I do, construction work, sometimes you finish your job the man don't have no where to send you. You might be off a couple of weeks, maybe two or three months, sometimes long enough to draw unemployment. I faced all of that kind of stuff but made a suit, a new suit. Like Jackie Robinson, I started in '47. He didn't play ball for fifty years but I masked all that time except for one year."23
Thus, we understand the depth of Tootie's announcement to his mother that he was going to start masking Indian. "Now, when I first said I wanted to mask as Indian, even though I was a married man, my momma said, 'What do you want to mask as Indian for, are you crazy?' I said, 'I want to mask as Indian. I'm a man, and I'm going to mask as Indian.'"24
The fundamental framework of a Mardi Gras Indian gang is a functional hierarchy. Montana spells out the positions: "You've got first chief, which is Big Chief; First Queen; you've got Second Chief and Second Queen; Third Chief and Third Queen. First, Second, and Third chiefs are supposed to have a queen with them. That's just tradition. I found them doing that. Your fourth chief is not called fourth chief, he's the Trail Chief. From there on it's just Indians, no title. You also have your Spy Boy, your Flag Boy and your Wild Man. Your Spy Boy is way out front, three blocks in front the chief. The Flag Boy is one block in front so he can see the Spy Boy up ahead and he can wave his flag to let the chief know what is going on. Today, they don't do like they used to. Today you're not going to see any Spy Boy with a pair of binoculars around his neck and a small crown so he can run. Today a Spy Boy looks like a chief and somebody carrying a big old stick. It's been years since I seen a proper flag. Today everybody has a chief stick. The Wild Man wearing the horns in there to keep the crowd open and to keep it clear. He's between the Flag Boy and the Chief."25
Between the nearly year-long sewing seasons and the Indian practices prior to Mardi Gras, the Mardi Gras Indian gangs compose a social organization which encompasses the most creative and most dedicated aspects of individual endeavor. Thus, to be an Indian is to make a social commitment and social statement, to dedicate one's resources, energy, and creativity to masking, procession, and ritual.
Though not often discussed, these are key elements in the Mardi Gras Indian tradition, elements which account for the stability of a social formation that has outlasted other traditions that have died out over the years. Mardi Gras Indians are more than beautiful. Tootie Montana is more than a Big Chief. The Mardi Gras Indians in general and Tootie Montana in particular are the pinnacle of artistic achievement in a country where excellent, community-based art activity is all but defunct.
1. Guide to ARC, LIGHT, A Series of Multi-Image Shows About Afro-Americans, Other Ethnic Groups, and Race Relations History. The Amistad Research Center, 37, 1983.
2. Leonard V. Huber, New Orleans A Pictorial History. New York: Crown, 1971, 11.
3. Michael Smith, "New Orleans' Hidden Carnival." Cultural Vistas. New Orleans: Louisiana Endowment for the Humanities, Autumn 1990, 20.
5. Maurice M. Martinez Jr., "Two Islands: The Black Indians of Haiti and New Orleans."
6. Arts Quarterly. New Orleans: New Orleans Museum of Art, July/August/September, 1979.
7. Barbara Bridges, "Black Indian Mardi Gras in New Orleans," in John W. Nunley and Judith Bettelheim, Caribbean Festival Arts. St. Louis: The Saint Louis Art Museum 1988. 163.
8. Ute Stebich, Haitian Art. New York: The Brooklyn Museum, 1978, 132.
9. Michael Smith, op. cit., 20.
10. Allison Montana, unpublished interview, 23 April 1997.
11. Allison Montana, unpublished interview, 30 July 1987.
12. Allison Montana, unpublished interview, 15 July 1987.
13. Allison Montana, unpublished interview, 23 April 1997.
20. Chernoff, John Miller. "The Drums of Dagbon." Repercussions, A Celebration of African-American Music. London: Century Publishing, 1985, 101.
21. Montana, Allison. Unpublished interview. 23 April 1997.